Discontinued Trader Joe’s Products That Shoppers Miss the Most

Trader Joe’s is notorious for discontinuing products, so much so that superfans will stockpile enough peppermint Hold the Cones to last years (seriously). Even then, some products never return, leaving Trader Joe’s shoppers feeling sad … and a bit resentful. In a popular Reddit thread, superfans shared their favorite discontinued items that they’re still “bitter” about. We’ve made a list of the most popular products from that thread, but don’t hesitate to add your own in the comments.

Related: Here’s Why Trader Joe’s Sells Out of Your Favorite Products So Quickly

While Change.org campaigns are usually reserved to pressure Congress or corporations, Trader Joe’s fans felt strongly enough about the retailer’s discontinued chocolate pudding that they started their own petition. Superfans are just as impassioned on Reddit, where the discontinued pudding received the most upvotes in this thread.

Related: Best Store-Bought Desserts from Trader Joe's

Redditors reminisced about the chain’s gorgonzola crackers, which one superfan said were “perfection” when paired with the store's tomato bisque. Truly desperate shoppers should know that they can buy a two-pack of the crackers from Amazon for $45.

For more fun and useful grocery stories, please sign up for our free newsletters.

After this frozen favorite went out of stock in 2021, Redditors speculated that the manufacturer simply stopped producing private-label versions of its mashed potatoes. Superfans lamented the departure, though one shopper notes that other grocery stores sell similar Grown in Idaho-brand frozen mashed potatoes.

Redditors say that while Trader Joe’s still offers corn tamales, the original sweet corn variety was far superior. “I forgot about those tamales. Man, those were delicious,” one superfan commented.

Alas, Trader Joe’s has axed the pumpernickel pretzels. But shoppers shouldn’t despair, as multiple superfans speculate that the retailer’s pretzels were just rebranded Utz pumpernickel sticks, which are available at other grocery stores.

Vegetarians went crazy for these breaded eggplant cutlets, which one Redditor says were perfect for a quick and convenient eggplant parm. “I've made my own from scratch but they are So. Much. Work,” one superfan wrote, adding a sad face emoticon.

This pre-packaged favorite came with stuffed grape leaves, hummus, and two salads. While you won’t be able to pick it up in stores anymore, Redditors have shared copycat recipes of the lentil salad in the past.

Related: ‘5 Items or Less:’ Trader Joe’s Recipes From an Instagram Favorite

These fry-shaped potato chips debuted in 2019, only to be discontinued two years later. One Redditor suggested the Filipino snack Pik-Nik as a ketchup-flavored alternative.

Only true Trader Joe’s heads will remember these thin, flatbread-like pizzas, which were discontinued years ago. “They got me through college and I crave them,” a Redditor shared.

Redditors mourned the loss of this spicy pasta sauce, which Trader Joe’s discontinued earlier this year. “Omg noooo! I didn’t even realize they discontinued the (arrabbiata) sauce until this comment! I wish I knew! I would’ve stocked up,” one disappointed Redditor commented.